Thickener Rake Torque & Underflow Clarity — Control Design
Shared by TSIMEREZIVO Team · 4 Oct 2026 · 37 views
# Mining Template: Thickener Rake Torque & Underflow Clarity
## 1. Overview
**Purpose:**
A thickener (settling tank, 20–50 m diameter) allows coarse solids to settle under gravity while water overflows as clarified product. A rotating rake mechanism slowly scrapes settled solids toward a central pump cone (underflow discharge). Rake torque monitoring indicates bed density: high torque = thick bed (good separation), excessive torque = bridge (solids locked up). Low torque = too dilute. The controller adjusts feed flow and rake speed to maintain optimal torque while monitoring underflow clarity (turbidity) as a quality indicator.
**Industry Standards:**
- ISO 6982 (Slurry Sedimentation Apparatus)
- ASME B103.1M (Sedimentation & Filtration Equipment Design)
- EPA 40 CFR Part 133 (Secondary Treatment)
**Critical Constraints:**
- **Rake torque range:** 5–20 kN·m typical; <3 = under-settled, >25 = bridge/blockage
- **Overflow clarity:** <100 NTU (nephelometric turbidity units) acceptable; <50 NTU preferred
- **Rake speed:** 0.5–2 rpm typical; too fast = re-suspension, too slow = bridging
- **Underflow density:** typically 30–50% solids by volume; higher = less water recycle cost
- **Feed distribution:** must spread uniformly across thickener diameter or solids won't settle evenly
- **Residence time:** minimum 2–4 hours for adequate settling; insufficient time → high overflow turbidity
**Relevant Physics:**
- **Settling velocity (Stokes):** $v_s = \frac{g d^2 (\rho_p - \rho_f)}{18 \mu}$ (particle diameter, density difference, viscosity)
- **Torque on rake:** $\tau = \mu_{apparent} \times \omega \times r^3$ (viscosity, angular velocity, radius); proportional to bed density
- **Batch settling curve:** initially linear, then parabolic tail; final hindered settling at slowest rate
- **Underflow density:** controlled by pump speed & orifice size; higher density = lower water loss
---
## 2. Control Philosophy
```
LAYER 1: Rake Torque Monitoring
Target torque: 12 kN·m (optimal bed density)
If torque < 8 kN·m: bed too dilute → reduce feed or increase rake speed (re-suspend)
If torque > 20 kN·m: bed too dense or bridge → reduce rake speed or "bump" reverse
LAYER 2: Underflow Clarity (Turbidity Feedback)
Measure overflow turbidity (NTU)
If turbidity rising (>100 NTU): inadequate settling → increase residence time or reduce feed
If turbidity stable & low (<50): optimal separation achieved
LAYER 3: Rake Speed Optimization
Base speed: 1 rpm (typical)
Increase speed (slow down settling) if torque too high (risk of bridge)
Decrease speed (allow settling) if torque low (dilute)
LAYER 4: Feed Rate Cascade
Target: maintain rake torque near setpoint
If torque high: reduce feed to thin bed
If torque low: increase feed to thicken bed (up to capacity)
LAYER 5: Bridge Detection & Recovery
If torque suddenly spikes & stays high: bridge
Action: reverse rake briefly (backward 10 sec), then resume forward at reduced speed
```
---
## 3. Control Logic (Condensed)
```pascal
{ === THICKENER RAKE & UNDERFLOW CLARITY CONTROL === }
PROCEDURE Thickener_Control_Master
CONSTANTS
RAKE_TORQUE_SETPOINT_KNM = 12 { optimal density }
RAKE_TORQUE_TOLERANCE_KNM = 3 { ±3 kN·m acceptable }
RAKE_TORQUE_HIGH_LIMIT_KNM = 20 { overload warning }
RAKE_TORQUE_BRIDGE_LIMIT_KNM = 25 { definite blockage }
RAKE_SPEED_MIN_RPM = 0.5
RAKE_SPEED_MAX_RPM = 2.0
RAKE_SPEED_NOMINAL_RPM = 1.0
OVERFLOW_TURBIDITY_TARGET_NTU = 50 { clarity goal }
OVERFLOW_TURBIDITY_ALARM_NTU = 100 { poor separation }
UNDERFLOW_DENSITY_TARGET_PCT = 40 { solids % }
THICKENER_DIAMETER_M = 40 { typical large thickener }
THICKENER_DEPTH_M = 4
RESIDENCE_TIME_TARGET_HR = 3
VARIABLES
rake_torque_measured_knm : REAL { torque sensor }
rake_torque_error_knm : REAL
rake_speed_setpoint_rpm : REAL
rake_speed_actual_rpm : REAL { motor feedback }
overflow_turbidity_ntu : REAL { clarity meter }
overflow_turbidity_trend_ntu_per_hr : REAL
underflow_density_pct : REAL { concentration sensor }
underflow_flow_rate_t_hr : REAL { pump discharge meter }
feed_flow_rate_t_hr : REAL
feed_flow_setpoint_t_hr : REAL
bridge_detected : BOOLEAN
bridge_counter : INTEGER
thickener_status : ENUMERATION { NORMAL | DILUTE | DENSE | BRIDGE | POOR_CLARITY }
rake_torque_history[1..60] : REAL { last 60 minutes for trending }
clarity_history[1..60] : REAL
BEGIN
{ === SENSOR INPUT === }
rake_torque_measured_knm = Read_Rake_Torque_Transducer()
rake_speed_actual_rpm = Read_Rake_Motor_Speed()
overflow_turbidity_ntu = Read_Turbidity_Meter()
underflow_density_pct = Read_Concentration_Sensor()
underflow_flow_rate_t_hr = Read_Pump_Discharge_Flowmeter()
feed_flow_rate_t_hr = Read_Feed_Flowmeter()
{ === TORQUE TREND ANALYSIS === }
{ Shift history }
FOR i = 60 DOWNTO 2 DO
rake_torque_history[i] = rake_torque_history[i−1]
END FOR
rake_torque_history[1] = rake_torque_measured_knm
{ === BRIDGE DETECTION === }
IF rake_torque_measured_knm > RAKE_TORQUE_BRIDGE_LIMIT_KNM THEN
bridge_detected = TRUE
bridge_counter = bridge_counter + 1
IF bridge_counter > 5 THEN { sustained high torque >5 scans }
Log_Alarm("THICKENER_BRIDGE_DETECTED_REVERSING_RAKE", torque=rake_torque_measured_knm)
{ Attempt bridge recovery: reverse rake }
Command_Rake_Motor(−1.0) { reverse at 1 rpm }
WAIT 10000_ms { hold 10 seconds }
Command_Rake_Motor(RAKE_SPEED_NOMINAL_RPM) { resume forward at reduced speed }
bridge_counter = 0
END IF
thickener_status = BRIDGE
ELSIF rake_torque_measured_knm > RAKE_TORQUE_HIGH_LIMIT_KNM THEN
bridge_detected = FALSE
bridge_counter = 0
thickener_status = DENSE
Log_Warning("RAKE_TORQUE_HIGH", torque=rake_torque_measured_knm)
ELSE
bridge_detected = FALSE
bridge_counter = 0
END IF
{ === RAKE TORQUE & SPEED CONTROL === }
rake_torque_error_knm = RAKE_TORQUE_SETPOINT_KNM − rake_torque_measured_knm
{ If torque too high: reduce rake speed (slow settling to allow drainage) }
IF rake_torque_measured_knm > RAKE_TORQUE_HIGH_LIMIT_KNM THEN
rake_speed_setpoint_rpm = RAKE_SPEED_NOMINAL_RPM × 0.6 { slow to 0.6 rpm }
{ If torque too low: increase rake speed (increase shear, reduce settling) }
ELSIF rake_torque_measured_knm < RAKE_TORQUE_SETPOINT_KNM − 5 THEN
rake_speed_setpoint_rpm = RAKE_SPEED_NOMINAL_RPM × 1.4 { speed to 1.4 rpm }
ELSE
{ Normal range: maintain nominal speed }
rake_speed_setpoint_rpm = RAKE_SPEED_NOMINAL_RPM
END IF
{ Enforce limits }
IF rake_speed_setpoint_rpm < RAKE_SPEED_MIN_RPM THEN
rake_speed_setpoint_rpm = RAKE_SPEED_MIN_RPM
END IF
IF rake_speed_setpoint_rpm > RAKE_SPEED_MAX_RPM THEN
rake_speed_setpoint_rpm = RAKE_SPEED_MAX_RPM
END IF
Command_Rake_Motor(rake_speed_setpoint_rpm)
{ === FEED RATE CASCADE === }
{ Primary control loop: maintain torque via feed rate }
{ Reduce feed if torque high; increase feed if torque low }
feed_flow_setpoint_t_hr = feed_flow_rate_t_hr + (rake_torque_error_knm × 2) { 2 t/hr per kN·m }
{ Cap at reasonable limits }
IF feed_flow_setpoint_t_hr < 10 THEN feed_flow_setpoint_t_hr = 10 END IF
IF feed_flow_setpoint_t_hr > 100 THEN feed_flow_setpoint_t_hr = 100 END IF
Command_Feed_Pump_Setpoint(feed_flow_setpoint_t_hr)
{ === OVERFLOW CLARITY MONITORING === }
{ Track turbidity trend }
IF MOD(scan_count, 10) = 0 THEN
FOR i = 60 DOWNTO 2 DO
clarity_history[i] = clarity_history[i−1]
END FOR
clarity_history[1] = overflow_turbidity_ntu
overflow_turbidity_trend_ntu_per_hr =
(clarity_history[1] − clarity_history[60]) / 60
END IF
{ If clarity rising (getting worse), reduce feed or increase residence time }
IF overflow_turbidity_ntu > OVERFLOW_TURBIDITY_ALARM_NTU THEN
thickener_status = POOR_CLARITY
Log_Alarm("OVERFLOW_CLARITY_POOR", turbidity_ntu=overflow_turbidity_ntu)
{ Emergency response: reduce feed by 20% }
feed_flow_setpoint_t_hr = feed_flow_setpoint_t_hr × 0.8
ELSIF overflow_turbidity_ntu > OVERFLOW_TURBIDITY_TARGET_NTU THEN
Log_Warning("OVERFLOW_CLARITY_ABOVE_TARGET", turbidity_ntu=overflow_turbidity_ntu)
END IF
{ === UNDERFLOW DENSITY OPTIMIZATION === }
{ Underflow density controlled by pump speed & dilution water }
{ Target: 40% solids; if lower, reduce dilution; if higher, add water }
IF underflow_density_pct < (UNDERFLOW_DENSITY_TARGET_PCT − 5) THEN
{ Too dilute; reduce water addition (close dilution valve) }
Dilution_Water_Valve_Command(current_valve_pct × 0.9)
ELSIF underflow_density_pct > (UNDERFLOW_DENSITY_TARGET_PCT + 5) THEN
{ Too thick; add more dilution water }
Dilution_Water_Valve_Command(current_valve_pct × 1.1)
END IF
{ === STATUS ASSIGNMENT === }
IF rake_torque_measured_knm < (RAKE_TORQUE_SETPOINT_KNM − RAKE_TORQUE_TOLERANCE_KNM) THEN
thickener_status = DILUTE
ELSIF rake_torque_measured_knm > (RAKE_TORQUE_SETPOINT_KNM + RAKE_TORQUE_TOLERANCE_KNM) THEN
thickener_status = DENSE
ELSIF bridge_detected THEN
thickener_status = BRIDGE
ELSIF overflow_turbidity_ntu > OVERFLOW_TURBIDITY_TARGET_NTU THEN
thickener_status = POOR_CLARITY
ELSE
thickener_status = NORMAL
END IF
{ === DATA LOGGING (every 30 min) === }
IF MOD(scan_count, 1800) = 0 THEN
Log_Process_Data({
timestamp: Get_Timestamp(),
rake_torque_knm: rake_torque_measured_knm,
rake_speed_rpm: rake_speed_actual_rpm,
overflow_turbidity_ntu: overflow_turbidity_ntu,
underflow_density_pct: underflow_density_pct,
feed_flow_t_hr: feed_flow_rate_t_hr,
underflow_flow_t_hr: underflow_flow_rate_t_hr,
thickener_status: thickener_status,
bridge_detected: bridge_detected
})
END IF
END PROCEDURE
```
---
## 4. Tag List
```
RAKE_TORQUE_MEASURED_KNM { load cell feedback }
RAKE_TORQUE_SETPOINT_KNM { target density }
RAKE_TORQUE_ERROR_KNM { deviation }
RAKE_SPEED_SETPOINT_RPM { motor command }
RAKE_SPEED_ACTUAL_RPM { motor feedback }
OVERFLOW_TURBIDITY_NTU { clarity meter }
OVERFLOW_TURBIDITY_TREND_NTU_HR { quality trend }
UNDERFLOW_DENSITY_PCT { concentration }
UNDERFLOW_FLOW_T_HR { pump output }
FEED_FLOW_T_HR { slurry input }
BRIDGE_DETECTED { boolean }
THICKENER_STATUS { NORMAL|DILUTE|DENSE|BRIDGE|POOR }
DILUTION_WATER_VALVE_CMD_PCT { underflow adjustment }
```
---
## 5. Alarm & Trip Matrix
| **Condition** | **Severity** | **Action** |
|---|---|---|
| **Torque > 25 kN·m** | 🔴 CRIT | Reverse rake 10 sec; check bridge |
| **Torque > 20 kN·m** | ⚠ WARN | Slow rake; reduce feed 20% |
| **Clarity > 100 NTU** | ⚠ WARN | Reduce feed 20%; increase RT |
| **Underflow too dilute** | ⚠ WARN | Close dilution water valve |
| **Underflow too thick** | ⚠ WARN | Open dilution water valve |
---
**Document Version:** 1.0
**Last Updated:** 2026-04-13
**Status:** Ready for Production