Boiler Feedwater Pump Pressure Control — Control Design
Shared by TSIMEREZIVO Team · 4 Oct 2026 · 42 views
# TSIMEREZIVO Template: Boiler Feedwater Pump Pressure Control
**Category:** Power Plant | **Industry:** Thermal Power Generation | **Language:** Ladder / Structured Text
---
## 📋 Overview
### Purpose
Maintain boiler feedwater pump discharge pressure at precisely 180–200 bar to overcome boiler steam drum pressure (175 bar at design) plus pipe friction losses (~15–20 bar) while minimizing energy waste. Too high = relief valve spills energy; too low = boiler couldn't fill; too dynamic = oscillations excite piping resonance.
### Typical Application
- **Pump Type:** Multi-stage centrifugal; 50–300 MW thermal plant
- **Nominal Capacity:** 100–250 kg/s feed flow (scales with plant output)
- **Pump Suction (from deaerator):** 0.3–0.5 bar absolute
- **Discharge Pressure Target:** 185 bar (nominal)
- **Bypass/Relief Valve:** Set to 200 bar (protects pump, wasteful if used continuously)
- **VFD Motor Drive:** Allows speed modulation OR fixed-speed pump with proportional bypass valve
### Why This Matters
Feedwater pressure is the **third most-critical control** (after turbine speed and condenser vacuum):
- **Under-pressure:** Boiler drum level drops (cavitation cascade → dangerous)
- **Over-pressure:** Relief valve continuously dumps → $50K–$100K/day wasted steam energy
- **Instability:** Pressure oscillations couple to boiler level swell/shrink → loss of control
A well-tuned pump pressure controller saves **2–4% plant efficiency** vs. a constantly-relieving bypass system.
---
## 🎯 Control Philosophy
### Key Equations
**Pump Discharge Pressure Balance:**
```
P_discharge = P_suction + ΔP_pump − losses
Where:
P_suction = 0.4 bar absolute (deaerator head)
ΔP_pump = f(N²) where N = pump RPM
≈ 180 bar at rated speed (100 MW plants)
losses = pipe friction, check valve (2–5 bar typically)
P_discharge = 0.4 + 180 − 3.5 = 176.9 bar (nominal)
+ boiler safety margin = 185 bar setpoint
Density correction (hot water at 160°C):
ρ = 842 kg/m³ (vs. 1000 kg/m³ at 20°C) → 16% less dense
P_real = P_nominal × (ρ_160 / ρ_20) × (correction factor)
```
**Pump Head-Capacity Curve (Centrifugal):**
```
H [bar] = a − b × Q² + c × N²/1000
Where Q = volume flow (m³/h), N = speed (RPM)
Typical: H = 200 − 0.15×Q² + 1.8×(N/3000)²
At 2850 RPM, 100 m³/h:
H = 200 − 0.15×(100)² + 1.8×(2850/3000)² = 182 bar ✓
```
**Pump Affinity Laws (for VFD-driven pumps):**
```
Q ∝ N (flow proportional to speed)
H ∝ N² (head proportional to speed square)
Power ∝ N³ (power cubic — why VFD saves energy)
Reducing RPM from 3000 → 2850 (95%):
Flow reduces to 95% (OK, matches lower load)
Head reduces to 95²% = 90.25% (still sufficient)
Power reduces to 95³% = 85.7% (20% less motor power! ✓)
```
**Control Strategy: Pressure Feedback Loop**
```
Load Demand
│
▼
Boiler drum level low?
/
YES ─→ [Increase pump speed/pressure]
/
/ NO
/
Pressure feedback
│
├─ If P_discharge > 200 bar → Relief opens → Waste
│
├─ If P_discharge < 170 bar → Boiler can't fill
│
└─ If P_discharge = 185 bar → Optimal (just overcome resistance)
Two Implementation Options:
A) FIXED-SPEED PUMP + PROPORTIONAL BYPASS RELIEF
Simple, robust; ~5% continuous energy loss (relief valve open)
B) VFD-DRIVEN PUMP + CLOSED-LOOP PRESSURE PID
Complex, high-efficiency; can achieve <1% loss
Modern plant standard → build this version
```
### Control Loop: VFD Speed Modulation with Pressure Feedback
```
Boiler water level / load demand
│
┌────────┴────────┐
▼ ▼
P_discharge sensor Flow demand
│ │
├─────────────────┤
│ │
▼ ▼
[PID] [Feedforward]
│ │
├─────────────────┤
│
▼
VFD Speed Command (RPM)
│
▼
Pump speed increases/decreases
→ Head (ΔP) changes via N² law
→ Pressure setpoint reached
→ Relief valve stays closed ✓
```
**PID Loop Tuning:**
- **Proportional Gain (Kp):** 0.05 — moderate response (pressure is slow thermal lag)
- **Integral Gain (Ki):** 0.003 — gentle correction (pump thermal mass is large)
- **Derivative (Kd):** 0 — NO derivative (causes hunting on pressure spikes)
Why gentle tuning? Pump thermodynamic response is slow (5–15 second lag from RPM change to final pressure).
---
## 🏗️ Control Logic
### Pseudocode: Boiler Feedwater Pump Pressure Control (VFD-Driven)
```pascal
PROGRAM BoilerFeedwaterPumpPressureControl;
{ ========== DECLARATIONS ========== }
VAR
-- INPUT SENSORS
pump_discharge_pressure : REAL; { 0-250 bar, 4-20 mA transmitter }
pump_discharge_temperature : REAL; { 100-180 °C, RTD input }
pump_suction_pressure : REAL; { 0-1 bar absolute, low-range sensor }
pumpm_speed_feedback : REAL; { 0-3600 RPM, tachometer }
pump_motor_current : REAL; { 0-500 A, current transducer }
boiler_drum_level : REAL; { 0-100 %, for load indication }
boiler_steam_pressure : REAL; { 0-250 bar, main steam pressure }
relief_valve_position : REAL; { 0-100 %, bypass flow feedback or direct measurement }
-- CONTROL SETPOINTS
pump_pressure_sp : REAL := 185.0; { Target discharge pressure }
pump_pressure_alarm_high : REAL := 210.0; { Over-pressure warning }
pump_pressure_trip_high : REAL := 215.0; { Relief valve stuck open? }
pump_pressure_alarm_low : REAL := 165.0; { Under-pressure warning }
pump_pressure_trip_low : REAL := 155.0; { Critical low }
relief_valve_cracking : REAL := 200.0; { Relief setpoint (fixed) }
-- CONTROL LOOP STATE
pressure_error : REAL;
pressure_error_integral : REAL := 0.0;
pressure_prev : REAL := 185.0;
-- VFD COMMAND
vfd_speed_command_rpm : REAL;
vfd_speed_limited : REAL;
vfd_speed_rate_limit : REAL := 10.0; { Max RPM/sec change }
vfd_speed_command_prev : REAL := 3000.0;
-- PID TUNING
kp_pump : REAL := 0.05; { Proportional: slow response }
ki_pump : REAL := 0.003; { Integral: minimum for slow plant }
kd_pump : REAL := 0.0; { NO derivative (oscillation risk) }
integral_limit_hi : REAL := 50.0; { Max +integral output: ±50 RPM }
integral_limit_lo : REAL := -50.0;
scan_time : REAL := 1.0; { 1-second scan (faster than deaerator) }
-- FEEDFORWARD TERM (Optional enhancement)
boiler_load_percent : REAL;
ff_speed_base : REAL; { RPM to just overcome static head }
-- ENERGY MONITORING
relief_valve_flow_est : REAL; { Estimated flow being dumped }
wasted_power_mw : REAL; { Power dissipated in relief }
-- PRESSURE QUALITY INDICATORS
pressure_oscillation_pk : REAL := 0.0; { Track peak oscillation }
pressure_stability_index : REAL := 0.0; { Increasing = getting worse }
-- OUTPUT COMMANDS
vfd_frequency_command : REAL; { 0-60 Hz output to VFD drive }
BEGIN
{ ========== SENSOR ACQUISITION & DIAGNOSIS ========== }
-- Calculate pump delta-P (head generated)
pump_head_bar := pump_discharge_pressure - pump_suction_pressure;
-- Estimate relief valve flow (if relief cracked open)
-- Relief opens at 200 bar; discharge trying to go higher
IF pump_discharge_pressure > relief_valve_cracking THEN
relief_valve_flow_est := (pump_discharge_pressure − relief_valve_cracking) × 0.5; { Rough estimate }
ELSE
relief_valve_flow_est := 0.0;
END_IF;
-- Estimate wasted power (relief dissipation)
wasted_power_mw := (relief_valve_flow_est [kg/s] × 0.001 [m³/kg] × (pump_discharge_pressure − 1) [bar]) / 25;
{ ========== ERROR CALCULATION ========== }
pressure_error := pump_pressure_sp - pump_discharge_pressure;
{ ========== FEEDFORWARD INITIALIZATION ========== }
-- Estimate required pump speed based on boiler load level
-- At full load: ~185 bar needed. At
light load: ~170 bar is sufficient.
boiler_load_percent := boiler_drum_level; { Proxy for demand }
-- Base speed needed to overcome static delta-P (boiler steam − suction + friction)
static_dp_required := (boiler_steam_pressure − pump_suction_pressure) + 10.0; { ~10 bar friction margin }
-- Using N² law: N required ∝ sqrt(P required)
ff_speed_base := 3000.0 × SQRT(static_dp_required / 185.0); { ~2850–2950 RPM @ full load, adjusted for pressure }
{ ========== PROPORTIONAL CONTROL ========== }
-- Smooth proportional term: negative error (too much pressure) → reduce RPM
proportional_term := kp_pump * pressure_error; { In RPM units }
{ ========== INTEGRAL CONTROL (Slow Correction) ========== }
-- Integral only adjusts for steady-state offset (e.g., seasonal density changes)
integral_term := integral_term + (ki_pump * pressure_error * scan_time);
-- Anti-windup
IF integral_term > integral_limit_hi THEN
integral_term := integral_limit_hi;
ELSIF integral_term < integral_limit_lo THEN
integral_term := integral_limit_lo;
END_IF;
{ ========== COMBINED VFD COMMAND ========== }
-- Base speed (feedforward) + proportional adjustment + integral trim
vfd_speed_command_rpm := ff_speed_base + proportional_term + integral_term;
{ ========== RATE LIMITING (Anti-Shock) ========== }
-- Prevent sudden speed swings that would cause pressure spikes
speed_delta := vfd_speed_command_rpm - vfd_speed_command_prev;
max_delta := vfd_speed_rate_limit * scan_time;
IF speed_delta > max_delta THEN
vfd_speed_limited := vfd_speed_command_prev + max_delta;
ELSIF speed_delta < -max_delta THEN
vfd_speed_limited := vfd_speed_command_prev - max_delta;
ELSE
vfd_speed_limited := vfd_speed_command_rpm;
END_IF;
{ ========== HARD OUTPUT LIMITS ========== }
-- Pump physical limits: 800 RPM (minimum stable) to 3600 RPM (motor nameplate)
IF vfd_speed_limited < 800.0 THEN
vfd_speed_limited := 800.0;
ELSIF vfd_speed_limited > 3600.0 THEN
vfd_speed_limited := 3600.0;
END_IF;
{ ========== CONVERT RPM TO VFD FREQUENCY ========== }
-- Standard formula: Frequency [Hz] = RPM / 120 × Poles
-- For 4-pole motor (60 Hz = 1800 RPM): Frequency = RPM × 60 / 1800 = RPM / 30
-- For 2-pole motor (60 Hz = 3600 RPM): Frequency = RPM / 60
-- Assume 2-pole: 3000 RPM = 50 Hz
vfd_frequency_command := (vfd_speed_limited / 3000.0) × 50.0; { Scale to 50 Hz nominal }
{ ========== ALARMS & CHECKS ========== }
-- Check 1: Over-pressure (relief cracked open)
IF pump_discharge_pressure > pump_pressure_alarm_high THEN
{ WARN: "Pump discharge pressure high — {value} bar" }
END_IF;
IF pump_discharge_pressure > pump_pressure_trip_high THEN
{ ALARM: "Pump pressure critical — relief stuck OPEN? Check for blockage downstream" }
END_IF;
-- Check 2: Under-pressure (VFD maxed out? Suction issue?)
IF pump_discharge_pressure < pump_pressure_alarm_low THEN
{ WARN: "Pump discharge pressure low — {value} bar" }
END_IF;
IF pump_discharge_pressure < pump_pressure_trip_low THEN
{ ALARM: "Pump pressure CRITICAL — Boiler cannot be filled. Check pump suction (deaerator level?)" }
END_IF;
-- Check 3: VFD at maximum but still under-pressure?
IF vfd_speed_limited >= 3600.0 AND pump_discharge_pressure < 170.0 THEN
{ ALARM: "VFD saturated at max speed but pump still weak — pump cavitation or impeller wear?" }
END_IF;
-- Check 4: Pressure oscillating excessively?
pressure_change := ABS(pump_discharge_pressure - pressure_prev) / scan_time;
pressure_oscillation_pk := MAX(pressure_oscillation_pk, pressure_change);
IF pressure_oscillation_pk > 2.0 THEN { Bar/sec oscillation }
{ ALARM: "Pump pressure hunting — tuning adjustment needed or relief valve chattering" }
END_IF;
-- Check 5: Wasted power (relief open too much)
IF wasted_power_mw > 5.0 AND boiler_load_percent > 80.0 THEN
{ ALARM: "Excessive relief flow — adjust VFD response or check relief setpoint" }
{ This is costing $50K/day per MW wasted! }
END_IF;
-- Check 6: Pump motor overheating?
IF pump_motor_current > 450.0 A THEN
{ WARN: "Pump motor current high — {value} A — check water temperature and viscosity" }
END_IF;
-- Check 7: Suction pressure too low (cavitation risk)?
IF pump_suction_pressure < 0.2 THEN
{ ALARM: "Pump suction pressure critically low — deaerator level in trouble?" }
END_IF;
{ ========== ENERGY EFFICIENCY LOG ========== }
-- Record % of time relief valve is open
-- Goal: < 1% relief valve operation at steady state
IF relief_valve_flow_est > 1.0 THEN { More than 0.1 kg/s wasted }
relief_open_time += scan_time;
END_IF;
relief_open_percentage := (relief_open_time / total_time) × 100.0;
IF relief_open_percentage > 5.0 THEN
{ ACTION: "Review pump VFD tuning — relief operating >5% of time (poor efficiency)" }
END_IF;
{ ========== UPDATE STATE FOR NEXT CYCLE ========== }
pressure_prev := pump_discharge_pressure;
vfd_speed_command_prev := vfd_speed_limited;
{ ========== SEND COMMAND ========== }
-- Output: vfd_frequency_command (0-50 Hz output to VFD drive)
-- Output: pressure feedback for HMI display
END_PROGRAM;
```
---
## 🏷️ Tag List
### Analog Inputs (Sensors)
| Tag Name | Type | Range | Units | Description |
|----------|------|-------|-------|-------------|
| `PUMP_DISCHARGE_PRESSURE` | AI | 0–250 | bar | Main feedwater pump discharge (4-20 mA) |
| `PUMP_DISCHARGE_TEMP` | AI | 0–180 | °C | Discharge temperature (density compensation) |
| `PUMP_SUCTION_PRESSURE` | AI | 0–1 | bar abs | Suction from deaerator (low-range sensor) |
| `PUMP_SPEED_FEEDBACK` | AI | 0–3600 | RPM | Pump shaft speed tachometer |
| `VFD_OUTPUT_FREQUENCY` | AI | 0–60 | Hz | VFD actual frequency output (feedback) |
| `PUMP_MOTOR_CURRENT` | AI | 0–500 | A | Motor phase-to-neutral current |
| `BOILER_STEAM_PRESSURE` | AI | 0–250 | bar | Main steam header pressure (for load indication) |
| `RELIEF_VALVE_POSITION` | AI | 0–100 | % | Bypass valve crack opening (if available) |
### Analog Outputs (Command)
| Tag Name | Type | Range | Units | Description |
|----------|------|-------|-------|-------------|
| `PUMP_PRESSURE_SP` | REAL | 160–200 | bar | Setpoint (fixed or scheduled) |
| `PUMP_PRESSURE_ERROR` | REAL | −50 to +50 | bar | Error = SP − Actual |
| `VFD_FREQUENCY_COMMAND` | AO | 0–60 | Hz | 0-10 VDC output to VFD drive electronics |
| `VFD_SPEED_COMMAND` | REAL | 600–3600 | RPM | Desired pump speed (intermediate variable) |
| `RELIEF_ESTIMATED_FLOW` | REAL | 0–300 | kg/s | Calculated bypass flow (diagnostic) |
| `WASTED_POWER_MW` | REAL | 0–10 | MW | Power dissipated in relief valve |
### Discrete Signals
| Tag Name | Type | Logic | Description |
|----------|------|-------|-------------|
| `PUMP_PRESSURE_HI_WARN` | DO | Latched | Pressure > 210 bar (warning) |
| `PUMP_PRESSURE_HI_TRIP` | DO | Latched | Pressure > 215 bar (critical) |
| `PUMP_PRESSURE_LO_WARN` | DO | Latched | Pressure < 165 bar (check suction) |
| `PUMP_PRESSURE_LO_TRIP` | DO | Latched | Pressure < 155 bar (boiler cannot fill) |
| `VFD_AT_MAX_SPEED` | DO | Auto | VFD frequency = 50 Hz (saturated) |
| `RELIEF_VALVE_OPEN` | DO | Calculated | Relief valve flow > 1 kg/s |
| `PUMP_CAVITATION_RISK` | DO | Auto | Suction pressure < 0.2 bar |
| `MOTOR_OVERTEMP_RISK` | DO | Latched | Motor current > 450 A for >5 min |
| `PRESSURE_HUNTING` | DO | Latched | Oscillation rate > 2 bar/sec |
---
## 🚨 Alarm & Trip Matrix
| Condition | Threshold | Severity | Action | Recovery |
|-----------|-----------|----------|--------|----------|
| **Pressure High (Warn)** | > 210 bar | ⚠️ WARN | Monitor; check relief seat for leakage | <200 bar |
| **Pressure High (Trip)** | > 215 bar | 🔴 TRIP | Stop pump; inspect relief valve | Relief repair needed |
| **Pressure Low (Warn)** | < 165 bar | ⚠️ WARN | Check deaerator level; boost VFD if possible | >170 bar |
| **Pressure Low (Trip)** | < 155 bar | 🔴 TRIP | Reduce load; fill boiler from auxiliary pump | Investigate root cause |
| **Relief Valve Stuck** | Pressure > 200 bar + relief open | 🔴 CRIT | Bypass valve cartridge stuck; manual operation | Disassemble/clean relief |
| **Pump Cavitation** | Suction < 0.2 bar + noise | 🔴 CRIT | Boost deaerator level; check for restrictions | Deaerator repair |
| **VFD Saturated** | Speed = 3600 + P < 170 bar | 🔴 CRIT | Pump impeller damaged or very worn | Pump inspection/replacement |
| **Pressure Hunting** | Oscillation > 2 bar/sec | ⚠️ WARN | PID tuning issue or relief chattering | Retune Kp/Ki or clean relief |
| **Relief Excessive** | >5% duty cycle | ⚠️ WARN | Energy waste ($50K+/day); tuning degraded | Retune VFD loop |
| **Motor Overload** | Current > 450 A sustained | ⚠️ WARN | Check water temperature & viscosity | Cool discharge water |
---
## 📺 HMI Layout
### Pump Pressure & VFD Control Panel
```
┌────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│ BOILER FEEDWATER PUMP PRESSURE & SPEED CONTROL │
├────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┤
│ │
│ ╔══════════ PRESSURE STATUS ══════════╗ │
│ ║ Discharge: 184.5 bar ║ │
│ ║ Setpoint: 185.0 bar ║ │
│ ║ Error: −0.5 bar (nominal) ║ │
│ ║ ║ │
│ ║ Suction: 0.39 bar (OK ✓) ║ │
│ ║ Relief: 200 bar (CLOSED ✓) ║ │
│ ║ ║ │
│ ║ Trend: ▃▃▃▃▄▄▄▄▅ stable ║ │
│ ╚═════════════════════════════════════╝ │
│ │
│ ╔══════════ VFD SPEED ═════════════════╗ │
│ ║ Command: 2985 RPM ║ │
│ ║ Feedback: 2984 RPM (sync ✓) ║ │
│ ║ Frequency: 49.7 Hz ║ │
│ ║ Motor Load: 385 A (77% rated) ║ │
│ ║ Power Out: 3.8 MW ║ │
│ ╚═══════════════════════════════════════╝ │
│ │
│ ╔════════ EFFICIENCY METRICS ═════════╗ │
│ ║ Relief Flow: 0 kg/s (0% duty) ║ │
│ ║ Wasted Power: 0 MW (optimal!) ║ │
│ ║ Uptime Today: 16 hours ✓ ║ │
│ ║ Relief Ops: < 1% excellent ║ │
│ ╚════════════════════════════════════════╝ │
│ │
│ ⚠️ [NONE] 🔴 [NONE] │
│ │
│ [ Load: 75% ] [ Set Pressure: 185.0 ▼ ] │
│ │
└────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┘
```
### 24-Hour Pressure Trend with Relief History
```
Pressure [bar]
220 ├─ Relief setpoint
210 ├──────────────────────────────────────────────
200 ├──╱╲ ╱╲
190 ├─╱ ╲────────╱ ╲─────────────────
180 ├/────────────────────────────────── ← Setpoint
170 ├────────────────────────────────────
160 └──00:00──06:00──12:00──18:00──00:00
Relief Flow [kg/s]
5 ├─╱ ╲ ╱ ╲
0 └───────────────────────────── ← Closed
Observations:
- Morning load ramp (05:00–08:00): Relief briefly opens 1 kg/s
- Midday (10:00–18:00): Relief closed (tuning good)
- Evening peak (19:00–20:00): Relief spikes to 3 kg/s (suboptimal)
```
---
## 🔧 Configuration Parameters
```json
{
"boiler_feedwater_pump": {
"description": "Feedwater pump discharge pressure PID with VFD speed control",
"nominal_setpoint_bar": 185.0,
"scan_time_sec": 1.0,
"pid_tuning": {
"proportional_gain_kp": 0.05,
"integral_gain_ki": 0.003,
"derivative_gain_kd": 0.0,
"integral_limit_hi_rpm": 50.0,
"integral_limit_lo_rpm": -50.0
},
"vfd_limits": {
"min_speed_rpm": 800.0,
"max_speed_rpm": 3600.0,
"rate_limit_rpm_per_sec": 10.0,
"nominal_motor_poles": 2,
"nominal_frequency_hz": 50.0
},
"pressure_alarms": {
"high_warning_bar": 210.0,
"high_trip_bar": 215.0,
"low_warning_bar": 165.0,
"low_trip_bar": 155.0,
"relief_valve_setpoint_bar": 200.0
},
"feedforward": {
"base_speed_calculation": "N = 3000 * sqrt(P_static_required / 185)",
"load_compensation": true,
"seasonal_density_correction": true
},
"efficiency_monitoring": {
"relief_open_threshold_kg_per_sec": 1.0,
"max_wasted_power_threshold_mw": 5.0,
"target_relief_duty_cycle_percent": 1.0
},
"commissioning": {
"min_discharge_pressure_at_full_load_bar": 175.0,
"target_margin_above_steam_pressure_bar": 10.0,
"expected_vfd_frequency_at_full_load_hz": 49.0
}
}
}
```
---
## 📝 Implementation Checklist
### Pre-Commissioning Design (1 day)
- [ ] Pump curve provided by manufacturer: head vs. flow at various speeds
- [ ] VFD drive rated for motor: kW rating ≥ pump motor nameplate
- [ ] Relief valve interlocked: opens only if discharge > 200 bar (no continuous bypass)
- [ ] Pressure transmitters installed: discharge (0–250 bar primary) + suction (0–1 bar secondary)
- [ ] Tachometer on pump shaft verified: 0–3600 RPM feedback
- [ ] Current transducer on motor: phase current measurement
- [ ] PID tuning baseline selected: Kp = 0.05, Ki = 0.003 (conservative)
- [ ] Affinity law calculations verified: N² relationship for head
- [ ] Alarm setpoints reviewed: high 210 bar, low 165 bar
### On-Site Installation (2 days)
**Day 1: Hardware & Electrical**
- [ ] VFD drive mounted, power wiring verified (3-phase 480V typical)
- [ ] Pump motor soft-start tested: no inrush current spike >1.5× nameplate
- [ ] Pressure transmitters calibrated: discharge at 185 bar = 12 mA output
- [ ] Tachometer signal verified: 3000 RPM = 50 Hz output
- [ ] PLC analog cards configured: 0–250 bar pressure input card, 0–60 Hz VFD output
- [ ] All interlocks wired: relief input, deaerator low-level signal
**Day 2: Control Loop Commissioning (Pump pressurised, not running)**
- [ ] Manual VFD test: command 20 Hz → observe pump speed rises smoothly
- [ ] Stop pump; increase command to 50 Hz; pressure visible on gauge
- [ ] Verify relief valve response: manually increase until relief cracks at 200 bar ✓
- [ ] Check proportional/integral response: small command change causes smooth pressure shift
### Hot Commissioning (4 days at power plant)
**Day 3: Soft-Start (Deaerator filled, pump to atmosphere)**
- [ ] Start pump at 10 Hz (low speed): pressure rises to ~20 bar (no load)
- [ ] Gradually increase to 50 Hz: pressure rises to ~180 bar (expected)
- [ ] Monitor discharge temperature: should NOT exceed 80°C at 50 Hz (no boiler backpressure yet)
- [ ] Zero cavitation noise: suction pressure stable >0.3 bar ✓
- [ ] Relief valve tested: increase speed until relief cracks → observe smooth bypass flow
**Day 4: Load Coupling (Connect to boiler steam drum at low pressure)**
- [ ] Boiler drum at 20 bar: pump delivers feed water at 30 bar discharge (easy)
- [ ] Pressure setpoint engaged: PID loop now active
- [ ] Monitor pressure oscillation: should settle within ±2 bar within 30 seconds
- [ ] Observe VFD speed adjustment: as drum pressure rises, VFD speed increases to maintain 185 bar SP
- [ ] Temperature rise at discharge: note baseline (typically +8–12°C rise across pump)
**Day 5: Full-Load Ramp Validation (100% steam generation)**
- [ ] Boiler steam pressure ramped to 175 bar (design pressure)
- [ ] Pump discharge pressure holds at 185 bar ±3 bar (acceptable tolerance)
- [ ] VFD frequency: ____ Hz (note baseline, typically 48–50 Hz)
- [ ] Motor current: ____ A (note baseline for future monitoring)
- [ ] Relief valve: CLOSED (no flow, 0% duty cycle) ✓
- [ ] **BASELINE CAPTURE:**
- VFD Frequency @ full load: ___ Hz
- Motor current @ full load: ___ A
- Discharge temp @ full load: ___ °C
- Pump suction pressure @ full load: ___ bar
- [ ] 2-hour stability run at constant load: zero relief operation, steady pressure
**Day 6–7: Transient & Fault Testing**
- [ ] Load increase (25% → 100%): relief stays closed; pressure holds <3 bar overshoot
- [ ] Load decrease (100% → 25%): pressure undershoots <2 bar; recovers in <30 sec
- [ ] Deaerator low-level alarm: pump suction pressure drops; controller reduces speed
- [ ] Manual relief bypass flow test: close outlet valve; relief opens; observe smooth energy dissipation
- [ ] VFD frequency tracking: check feedback = command within 1 Hz
---
## 📊 Expected Performance
### Steady-State Performance (Full-Load Operation)
| Parameter | Target | Allowable | Typical |
|-----------|--------|-----------|---------|
| **Discharge Pressure** | 185 bar | 180–190 bar | **185.2 bar** |
| **Pressure Stability** | ±2 bar | ±3 bar max | **±1.5 bar** |
| **Relief Valve Operation** | 0% duty cycle | < 1% | **0%** |
| **Wasted Power (Relief)** | 0 MW | < 1 MW | **0 MW** |
| **VFD Frequency** @ 175 bar steam | 49–50 Hz | 48–51 Hz | **49.3 Hz** |
| **Motor Current** @ full load | 380–400 A | < 450 A | **392 A** |
| **Discharge Temperature Rise** | 8–12°C | < 15°C | **10.8°C** |
| **Suction Pressure Margin** | > 0.3 bar | > 0.2 bar | **0.38 bar** |
### Transient Response
**Load Step: 25% → 100% (Turbine throttle open rapidly)**
| Time (sec) | Load (%) | P_discharge (bar) | VFD (Hz) | Relief Open |
|-----------|----------|-----------------|----------|-------------|
| 0 | 25 | 170 | 40 | No |
| 5 | 45 | 172 | 43 | No |
| 10 | 65 | 178 | 46 | No |
| 15 | 85 | 188 | 48 | Yes! (1.2 kg/s) |
| 20 | 100 | 187 | 49 | Yes (0.8 kg/s) |
| 30 | 100 | 185 | 49.3 | No ✓ |
| 60 | 100 | 185 | 49.3 | No (steady) |
**Notes:**
- Small overshoot to 188 bar at t=15 sec (acceptable, relief cracks to bleed excess)
- PID corrects back to 185 bar within 30 seconds
- No hunting; smooth convergence
---
## 🔄 Advanced Variations
### Variation A: Cascade Pressure Control (Multi-Stage Pump)
For very high discharge pressures (>250 bar) or large plants (>500 MW):
- **Master (Outer) Loop:** Final discharge pressure (185 bar target)
- **Slave (Inner) Loop:** Intermediate pump stage pressure (to prevent cavitation in later stages)
Both loops feed the same VFD command (master dominant).
### Variation B: Duty Cycling (Fixed-Speed Pump + Proportional Bypass)
Alternative to VFD:
- Pump runs fixed at 1500 RPM (50% speed) = ~90 bar head
- Proportional bypass valve modulates: open more = relief flow ↑
- Simpler control, but ~5–8% continuous energy loss
Loop would use proportional valve position instead of VFD frequency.
### Variation C: Load-Following Setpoint Scheduling
For power plants following grid demand:
- **Off-peak (night):** Setpoint 175 bar (reserve capacity)
- **Peak hours:** Setpoint 185 bar (maximum efficiency)
- Smooth ramp over 5 minutes (avoid transient shock)
---
## 📄 Document Version History
| Version | Date | Author | Change |
|---------|------|--------|--------|
| 1.0 | 2026-04-13 | Claude | Initial template: VFD speed PID + relief monitoring |
---
*This template is part of the TSIMEREZIVO Industrial Process Control Library.*